None of my favorites have ever won on American Idol . Anyone else ?!

I REALLY Wish Jason would have won!. He is the only one with a ORIGINAL DIFFERENT Sound!.!.!.Honestly how many David Cooks do we need!?!?!? We already have plenty!.!.!.sure they all sound great!.!.!.!.!.
David A!. Is good but I am a little curious what is his category!.!.!.!.!?!?!? Just balads!.!.!?!? we never got a type for him considering his DAD choses all his songs!.!.!.I dont know I cant wait till Jason has a CD cause I will buy it right away!.
Wont be buying David Cook!.!.!.!.as I already own his CD by 50 other Artist who sound just like him!!Www@Enter-QA@Com

---

---

Justin sucked!. He was horrible!. I didn't watch the first season, but I only saw the finale and I remember thinking "how the hell did this guy get through with this girl"!.
Clay/Rueben I think was the closest ever, but ya, Clay was the best!.
Melinda was too oldfashioned for me!.
Bo Bice didn't deserve to win over Carrie, she did great every week and could sing anything!.
Elliot was really good too, just not as charismatic!.
LaToya London, don't remeber her, is that the one that sang "rain on my parade" when she got kicked off!? if so, ya she was great too!.
This year, I think both Davids are great and I think they both deserve it!. One of the few times both of the top two were great!.Www@Enter-QA@Com

---

---

I was sad when Chris Daughtry and Melinda Doolittle got kicked off!. I almost stopped watching when Michael Johns and Carly got kicked off this season!. They all had wonderful voices, good stage personality, and were talented individuals!.

I really like David Cook!. I think he is more talented and has a better stage personality than David A!. also I see David Cook going farther career wise!. And he is hunky :)Www@Enter-QA@Com

---

---

Nah!. I had Carrie Underwood as my favorite and she won!. And she's to top of her game and one of the better Idols to have ever won!.

That was the only season I really wanted someone to really win!.

I liked Blake Lewis and he didn't win!.!.!.but not nearly as much as I liked Carrie Underwood!.

This season I just liked all the DAVIDS!. So I don't care which one wins!. I do think David A sings better, though!.!.!.or has the better potential to be the best singer!.

I said, from the beginning, that it would be a David and David finale!.!.!.so I like that!.Www@Enter-QA@Com

---

---

Well I didnt start watching till Season 4 but these are who I wanted to win:

4!.) Vonzell Solomon
5!.) Lisa Tucker
6!.) Melinda Doolittle - She should have won!.
7!.) I wanted Carly or Michael or David Cook so David still has a chance lolWww@Enter-QA@Com

---

---

American Idol represents everything that is wrong with the corporate music machine!.

Support independent artists- let the REAL musicians have a chance at the top for a change!.!.!.Www@Enter-QA@Com

---

---

American Idle is rigged!. Since the winner is only a 'pretend winner', you might feel better by pretending that you liked them all along!.Www@Enter-QA@Com

---

---

Jordin and Carrie i picked and was right so i got 2 right i started watching season 3Www@Enter-QA@Com

---

---

I really wanted Melinda to go farther last season!. Now I'm rooting for David A!.
Clay was better than Rueben too!.Www@Enter-QA@Com

---

---

I hope not, sorry

some years my fave won some they didn't!.
Hope this year my fave does! Go David Cook!Www@Enter-QA@Com

---

---

Jordin was my favorite!. I liked both Chris DAughtry and Taylor Hicks, it was a tie for me that season!.Www@Enter-QA@Com

---

---

i hope to god that david a will win!!!!!
i hope you are right
he deserves to win with everything but i feel a little bad for david cook
but what can i say i like david a beterWww@Enter-QA@Com

---

---