---

Answers: Or would you have preferred another act to go through instead? Personally, I don't really like the brother and sister act, i find them far too cheesy, and i would have preferred one of the other girls to have gone through instead of Kimberley as she is very annoying, and as for that weirdo Rhydian! Well how did that happen?

---

Lol, we were just talking about this in the office. No idea how Same Difference (Brother & Sister) made it through - I really liked Ghostt (the two brothers and their friend). I also thought the other girl band were much better than Hope - but I'm really pleased Cee Cee got chucked out, she was so annoying. That Rhydian guy is not going to be popular with the viewers and I would put money on him being out the first time he's in the public vote - oh it's soooo good :-)

---

I think that the show should have had a few years rest... The quality of the contestants has deteriorated a hell of a lot this time round...
I really can't see any of them finding any success however well they do on the show...

---

I am not sure if you can say whether acts are correct or incorrect to go through because we all have different opinions on what is good or not! We only see a snippet of the acts anyway so presumably the judges SHOULD know what they are doing!

---

i cant believe danni never put dominic through, he was fab, and why would simon put those donny & marie wannabees through but leave ghostt out, they were amazing!

---

I think the real question is do we really care?

---

They are nothing special, show is past its sell by date.

---

i hate rhydian, who does he think he is. Im thinking maybe his head is that big that he wont be able to fit through the door to get in onto the stage. Kimberley yes annoying but i didnt mind the brother and sister act, could do with some good role models on tv for kids and i think even tho cheesy they are just that

---

I think Louis was the only one to get it right out of what was in his group. That Rydian guy will be booted off in the first few weeks. He is so full of himself and I don't think the public will keep him in. I thought Dominic should have gone through. He was very good. The under 25 girls aren't very good this year and don't think any of the bands will make it too far either, Same Difference are just to way too cheesy. Well, they are supposed to be the experts, we will see!!!

---

NO WAY!!!!!! RIDIAN SHOULD HAVE BEEN KICKED OF AND NEVER EVEN GOT TO BOOT CAMP AND THAT LITTLE LAD SHOULD AVE BEEN KEPT ON INFACT ALL OF THE BOYS THAT GOT THROUGH SHOULD BEE SWAPED WITH THE ONES THAT GOT KICKED OUT its just a joke now
BUT MOST OF THE GIRLS WERE GOOD BUT THAT LASS THAT NEARLY DIED LAST YEAR WAS REALY GOOD RIDIAN WONT MAKE IT PAST THE FIRST LIVE SHOW (I HOPE)

---

I'm in agreement - I don't like the brother/sister group, but I also thought that putting that nutcase Icaro through at boot camp was a joke - there were several very talented people that deserved the chance.
Kimberley I think deserves it, she is a great singer, although I can see why people don't like her - I think she deserves the chance though.

Rhydian - don't even go there! I reckon he will be voted off pretty quickly - he has no likeability factor and loves himself a bit too much.

---

I agree the best acts weren't put through this time. I liked Ghost too. Rhydian, no one will vote for him because of his attitude, and Louis must know this.
The Brother and Sister are okay, but are not what the public want.
As for Icaro, did you see him on 'This Morning' this morning! Why on earth did he get as far as he did? I can see Chico all over again. It makes a mockery of the show, which, by the way, I still enjoy.
Although I still enjoy the X Factor there will never be another Will Young who was the first 'Pop Idol' winner. He's the best and always will be.

---

I cant believe Dominic and Ghost never got through! They were my 2 favourite Acts! x

---

I missed it!! aaaah

---

Well Simon was most definatly in la la land when he put his through for someone who says on a regular basis I quote:
"Sounds like a bar singer" then why oh why did he put brother and sister through?
I actually liked Kimberly and thought Sharon has a good crop also Walsh's are ok but did like the other Dan too.
Rhydian well what can I say how much time have you got good voice but has the personality of a spider her makes me scream. on forum up in arms about him get rid of rid is the post lol

---

I cant believe that Dominic wasnt put through, he was so talented, and the same goes for Ghostt. Two talented acts left behind while people with less talent go through. It seems more about what will make the show look good/diverse/ridiculous than about actual talent. How else did Icaro get through. As for Rhydian, hes there so people will have someone to hate, he has a good voice, but i wouldnt say it was a great voice.

---

Rhydian is an annoying nipple and will be out so fast, his feet won't touch the ground, if people have any sense! I know he can sing but the point of this competition is that they have to have a likability factor and he does not!! I was happy ish about everyone that got through apart from the groups, I think Ghostt should have gone through. That Cici woman having an outstanding conviction, no surprise! I am glad she has gone! Although, I did hear she is friends with Charley from Big Brother fame so that is no surprise!!

---

Maybe they should change the name to Y factor, or Y oh Y factor. A great misjustice has been done, most of the best singers got left out, barring that barmy Icaro. Get rid of Ryd and maybe someone with a modicum of talent will begin to shine, just maybe..

---

i thought steph should of gone through and rhydian i just cant stand him

---

No, I think Louis got it right with his over 25's, but the groups that got through were a joke. The two last-minute groups both got through - what's the odds against that happening. I'm not too keen on the brother/sister either - I don't think their voices go well together. Ghostt were robbed - they were the best group by a mile!!! I quite like Kimberley, although I agree she is annoying, but Rhydian???? well, it's all been said already - that guy is just so strange and his arrogance is unbelievable - I can't see him progressing too far.
I hope Beverley does well.

---

Do you believe in fairies too?

The whole show is rigged and fake, they already know who will win at the end of it all. It's panto and you're falling for it. Enjoy wasting all that money voting, because it will count for nothing.

---

I agree with most of the other answers, I loved Dominic and Ghostt and they got the boot. I think all the groups that got thru are crap, especially the brother and sister. They remind me of the scottish bros from last year.

Lets all vote Rhydian out on the first week if possible!

---

Nope x

If i had MY way...::

Boys::
Dominic
Andy
That other young blonde boy, can't think of his name

Girls::
Emily
Stephanie
Kimberly [[blonde bubbly one, not the boring one]]

Over 25s::
Niki
Dan
Bev
^^ WOOHOOO GO LOUIS ALL 3 :D

Groups::
Ghostt -- I thought they were absolutely fab i dont see how they didn't get through
Hope
Futureproof

Anyone agree..? xx

Love Alwaiiz xx

Nikkii <33

---

---