Which American Idol judge..?!
Question: Which American Idol judge!.!.!?
do you feel is the most on-point, meaning there is merit behind what he/she is saying!. The judge who is the fairest, the most knowledgeable and tells it the way you may be thinking at home!?
Personally, I only appreciate and listen to what Simon has to say!. He may say it ruthlessly, but I usually agree with whatever he is saying!. In fact, I feel that Paula(yes, crazy Paula) is more ON POINT about things than Randy!. Randy plays favorites and for no reason at all sometimes, says he dislikes preformances or "they are just okay" when the other judges, and the crowd, seems to love them!.
So, which judge do you think has the most merit!?Www@Enter-QA@Com
Personally, I only appreciate and listen to what Simon has to say!. He may say it ruthlessly, but I usually agree with whatever he is saying!. In fact, I feel that Paula(yes, crazy Paula) is more ON POINT about things than Randy!. Randy plays favorites and for no reason at all sometimes, says he dislikes preformances or "they are just okay" when the other judges, and the crowd, seems to love them!.
So, which judge do you think has the most merit!?Www@Enter-QA@Com
Answers:
What's up with Randy "booing" Simon when they get introduced!? So immature!!
Tonight Paula put Syesha down twice!. She hardly ever does that! I thought that was mean!.
I think Syesha will be very successful on Broadway!.
David Cook should win!. He'd be a good American Idol!.
David A!. looks like an overweight 5th grader!. He wears those stupid T-shirts and those stupid sneakers!.
Oh, to answer the question, Simon is by far the best judge, ALMOST always!. -LLWww@Enter-QA@Com
Tonight Paula put Syesha down twice!. She hardly ever does that! I thought that was mean!.
I think Syesha will be very successful on Broadway!.
David Cook should win!. He'd be a good American Idol!.
David A!. looks like an overweight 5th grader!. He wears those stupid T-shirts and those stupid sneakers!.
Oh, to answer the question, Simon is by far the best judge, ALMOST always!. -LLWww@Enter-QA@Com
Simon!. he's honest and he also knows what's good and bad in the music industry!. he tells it like how they should really hear it!. he's usually correct too!.
Paula!.!. all she says is, "oh you look beautiful tonight!." "you're such a lovely soul!." "you're so real" OKAY, we get it!.
Randy, i dont really care about what he says!.Www@Enter-QA@Com
Paula!.!. all she says is, "oh you look beautiful tonight!." "you're such a lovely soul!." "you're so real" OKAY, we get it!.
Randy, i dont really care about what he says!.Www@Enter-QA@Com
Definitely Simon!. I think he's absolutely honest and I usually agree with him too!. I don't think he's all that mean, either!. I think he's a really nice guy underneath!.!.!. Just look at his smile!. :) As for Paula!.!.!. I don't really get her!. Sometimes I wish she wouldn't speak!. And Randy gets really annoying saying "Yo!.!.!. Baby!.!.!. Dawg!.!.!. Man!."Www@Enter-QA@Com
B4 reading any of the other answers!.!.!.I go with Simon he is the usually right on with his comments good or bad!. Paula is wishy-washy with her answers!. Randy "dog" that was !.!.!. gets sickening but he is a producer so he knows what he likes!. Simon on a scale of 1-10 gets a 10 with me!.!!!Www@Enter-QA@Com
simon advice matters!.!.!.
whats wrong with paula!.!.!.can she just give th real advice!.!.!.like!.!.!.if the candidates performance really suck!.!.!.tell it!.!.!.
simon advice maybe hurting but the truth!.!.!.
truth really hurts!!Www@Enter-QA@Com
whats wrong with paula!.!.!.can she just give th real advice!.!.!.like!.!.!.if the candidates performance really suck!.!.!.tell it!.!.!.
simon advice maybe hurting but the truth!.!.!.
truth really hurts!!Www@Enter-QA@Com
Simon, even though I did not agree with his assessment of Syesha tonight!.Www@Enter-QA@Com
Usually Simon!
Then it would have to be Randy (without the yo yo yo Dawg crap all the time)
Paula just needs to check into AAWww@Enter-QA@Com
Then it would have to be Randy (without the yo yo yo Dawg crap all the time)
Paula just needs to check into AAWww@Enter-QA@Com
SIMON!!Www@Enter-QA@Com
good ole ruthless Simon!.!.!.he is right on and no matter what people say everybody listens and awaits for his answers!.!.!.Www@Enter-QA@Com
They all have merits in their own ways:
Simon for the most part!. But I don't know sometimes when he really does not know the song and then says it is terrible cabaret!.!.!.!.!.!.!.!.!.what is that!. Just listen to the voice! But he is the most honest and usually right on!. He tends to be right about who will move forward and who will be going home!. But he does have his days too, but we all do!. I have to admit I did not agree with his decision on David C's last song tonight but he was right on on the others!. The only reason I say that is because that song is an amazing song and I just thought it sounded bad!. But it takes an awesome singer to do an Aerosmith song justice!.!.!.!.especially that one!.
Randy is right I a lot of the time as well!. I like the encouragement and praise he gives to the contestants!.
Paula: Let's just say when she picks a fave then no one else sounds better than that person!. But these are just my opinions!.Www@Enter-QA@Com
Simon for the most part!. But I don't know sometimes when he really does not know the song and then says it is terrible cabaret!.!.!.!.!.!.!.!.!.what is that!. Just listen to the voice! But he is the most honest and usually right on!. He tends to be right about who will move forward and who will be going home!. But he does have his days too, but we all do!. I have to admit I did not agree with his decision on David C's last song tonight but he was right on on the others!. The only reason I say that is because that song is an amazing song and I just thought it sounded bad!. But it takes an awesome singer to do an Aerosmith song justice!.!.!.!.especially that one!.
Randy is right I a lot of the time as well!. I like the encouragement and praise he gives to the contestants!.
Paula: Let's just say when she picks a fave then no one else sounds better than that person!. But these are just my opinions!.Www@Enter-QA@Com
Simon is the only judge I will ever listen to!.
Obviously, Paula is not on-target!. She is just there to lighten the mood a little & I appreciate that!. But she is definitely not a professional when it comes to giving advice!.
Randy has completely lost my respect after this season!. His favoritism for little David has been obvious from the start, & it's starting to get quite fishy!. David Archuleta is good, no doubt, but he's not AMAZING!. The only characteristic he has that makes him incredible is his age, & with a little more time & maturity he will definitely be a great singer & performer!. As of now though, he is quite mediocre (no offense)!. Randy is a hypocrite!. He tells David Cook that he would prefer a song with more a rock-vibe, then after hearing a rock song, tells David Cook that it was predictable!. What more does he want!?
Randy has been totally off this season, & I could almost compare his judging skills to Paula!. Simon has been the most on target, though not all the time, & I am not just saying that because he consistently praises David Cook!. After all, David Cook deserves all the praise he gets!Www@Enter-QA@Com
Obviously, Paula is not on-target!. She is just there to lighten the mood a little & I appreciate that!. But she is definitely not a professional when it comes to giving advice!.
Randy has completely lost my respect after this season!. His favoritism for little David has been obvious from the start, & it's starting to get quite fishy!. David Archuleta is good, no doubt, but he's not AMAZING!. The only characteristic he has that makes him incredible is his age, & with a little more time & maturity he will definitely be a great singer & performer!. As of now though, he is quite mediocre (no offense)!. Randy is a hypocrite!. He tells David Cook that he would prefer a song with more a rock-vibe, then after hearing a rock song, tells David Cook that it was predictable!. What more does he want!?
Randy has been totally off this season, & I could almost compare his judging skills to Paula!. Simon has been the most on target, though not all the time, & I am not just saying that because he consistently praises David Cook!. After all, David Cook deserves all the praise he gets!Www@Enter-QA@Com