Why did the Judges Criticize Syeshas "song Choice" on 3rd song?!


Question: Why did the Judges Criticize Syeshas "song Choice" on 3rd song!?
I dont get why the Judges critized Syesha on the third song because of "her poor song Choice" because wasnt it the Producer that choose that song for her!? Im talking about the "Penguin Song" that she did on third round tonight (5/13/08)!?They critised her song choice but if I understood Correctly she wasnt the one who chose it!.!.!.!.Www@Enter-QA@Com


Answers:
They weren't criticizing her song choice!.!.!.they were criticizing the song itself lmaao!. It kinda seemed the same also with David A's last performance!.!.!.Simon was criticizing the song, and not him!.Www@Enter-QA@Com

I thought it was ridiculous for Simon to criticize the song!. The PRODUCERS picked that song, so Syesha had nothing to do with the choice!.!.!.she made a good performance out of a bad song!.

Simon focused on the fact that it was about penguins!.!.!.unfair to Syesha, now everybody will be thinking that way and that will hurt her votes!. (Tho she will not make it to the last 2 anyway)!. That girl is bound for Broadway, mark my words!. She's a good singer, but also a good PERFORMER!. She will go on in her career!.Www@Enter-QA@Com

you are absolutely right, they obviously had nothing bad to say about her singing so they picked on her song!. even with the song she chose they said nothing about her voice just the song!. so does this mean she does have talent and a great singing voice yes!! so all you nay sayers listen up !.!.!.syesha has so much talent that all the judges could do is pick on the choice of song, whether it was her choice or not!. they were practically pimping david A!. with the exception of micheal johns, what the judges decide everyone seems to go along with!. sayesha already put out a single on itunes!. she's better off not winning!. she'll do great!. she already proved to be the best female singer of them all and that is why she is in the top three!.Www@Enter-QA@Com

That has happened before, I remember clearly!. Somebody else choosing the song and the poor contestants being criticized for song choice ! It's crazy !!

Wait until next year, they'll do it again !Www@Enter-QA@Com

Yes you're right - the producers chose the last round of songs!.!.!.so like you said, it wasn't the singers faults that the song choices stunk!.!.!.Www@Enter-QA@Com

True but I think that she was focusing more on her dance than her voice!. I still liked it!. She choose the song (thats what I heard)Www@Enter-QA@Com



The answer content post by the user, if contains the copyright content please contact us, we will immediately remove it.
Copyright © 2007 enter-qa.com -   Contact us

Entertainment Categories