When Paula Abdul gets fired from American Idol, who do you think should take or !


Question: When Paula Abdul gets fired from American Idol, who do you think should take or place!?
"I don't for one second buy the explanation given by Paula herself, that she was momentarily confused and was reading her notes for David Cook; if that was the case, how come she changed course, seconds later, and told Cook he was ''fantastic''!? And I find it hard to believe Paula's flub was simply the result of her boarding the La-La Express; her critique of Jason's performance was far too specific!." <quote from entertainment weekly website

I think this may be her last year!. That was not just a small mistake, that was a mistake which may cost idol its credibiltiy!. Plus every week she spends forever blabbbering on about stuff that doesnt make any freakin sense!. I wouldnt be surprised if she got fired!. I read somewhere that for the past couple years American idol has been thinking about hiring Olivia Newton John instead of Paula!. That could work!.Www@Enter-QA@Com


Answers:
Well Miss Understood said what I was going to say!. (and pink monkey was right on too)

I think they make notes during rehearsals and since they told them it was a fast hour to be ready!. She had notes on both performances for the rehearsals!. She was flustered by the hurry up!.!.!.she is used to blathering on and on!. She might have been told to critique both performances and Ryan changed it up on her by asking them to say something about their first songs!.!?!?!? just giving her the benefit of doubt!.

I doubt she will go anywhere!.!.!.!.!.!.but since this is just a question and meant to be just a question!.!.(I don't understand the haters either!.!.!.like they all spell perfect all the time!.!.!.I find mistakes after I post all the time) they were just getting their two points!. It's just your opinion!.!.!.they don't have to agree they can respectfully post their opinion

if they want controversy how about Rosie!.!.!.hahaha no seriously!.!.Olivia Newton John would be ok!.!.!.If Paula is gone they can have the revolving third judge!.!.!.like the mentors can be a judge!.!.!.or other musical celebrities could do it!. I think it should be a singer though!.!.!.someone who has had to sing in front of people and stuff!.Www@Enter-QA@Com

I would love to see someone controversial that will argue with Simon and/or Randy, or maybe a comedian, like Ellen Degeneres or Dane Cook, who has no musical training (like most of us) and would give their honest opinion good or bad!. They are going to have to do something different to keep the show alive!.Www@Enter-QA@Com

OK, I'll answer your question the way your intended it to be answered!.!.!.

If for some reason Paula is not on the next Idol, I think Madonna would be a comparable nut case replacement!. I do like the Janet Jackson suggestion from earlier in Answers!.Www@Enter-QA@Com

She won't get fired if that ever happend i would hope that maybe scarey spice would do it since she's already interveiwed people on ETWww@Enter-QA@Com

How about Mariah Carey , she did a great job mentoring and knows alot about the technical side of singing,even though her career is hot right now , I can see her & Randy ganging up on Simon!.Www@Enter-QA@Com

Paula won't get fired!. She's perfect in that spot!. She's good balance between Randy and Simon!.Www@Enter-QA@Com

Lisa Simpson or Dora the explorerWww@Enter-QA@Com

No she's not gonna leave but if she does, I think one of the old contestants in previous years should be a judge!.Www@Enter-QA@Com

Jessica Simpson!. Just enough ditzyness to entertain!Www@Enter-QA@Com

Paula isnt going anywhere!. I agree with the poster who said that some people are blowing thing with Paula way out of proportion!.!.Its over and done with nada!. People needs to give it a rest!.Www@Enter-QA@Com

I think Janet Jackson would be good because she is so popular and knows what it takes to make it far!.Www@Enter-QA@Com

If she weren't a good judge, she wouldn't have been there all this time!. You're full of crapola!.Www@Enter-QA@Com

How old are you!? 12!?
Paula's not going anywhere!.Www@Enter-QA@Com

How about Michael Jackson!? He doesn't seem too busy these days!.Www@Enter-QA@Com

haha so trueWww@Enter-QA@Com

I wish i was level 2 so i could give some of these people thumbs down!!!! i agree on everything you said, as do millions of other people im sure! Paula is no longer a good judge, she gives the idols false hope because she just does not know how to be honest!. also the other night, that was a HUGE mistake she made, me and my friends were all sitting there like huh!?! Now its pretty clear that something goes on with American Idol that the public is not let in on!. But all the points you made were 100% valid!. I dont know why people are leaving such a hole comments!. Its ridiculous!.Www@Enter-QA@Com

Actually, I think since the show was going to be so rush-rush, the judges wrote down their notes in advance during soundcheck!. They do hear all of the performances during the Dress Rehearsals earlier in the day,which is how they determine the order they're performing in, so maybe that time the contestants each got to do their 2 songs back to back (how they SHOULD'VE done during the show)!. It was an honest mistake!. Anyway,though,I don't think they're replacing her,though!. I think that's the rumor that Ryan was addressing when he said she's "family"!.
But IF they did replace her and wanted another female Pop singer, I'd love to see Cyndi Lauper!. I love her!.She's funny and quirky and would definitely make the show interesting!. Or they could hire Kelly Clarkson,who was the first American Idol, afterall!. But I got so used to seeing Randy,Paula and Simon that I don't know if I'd want to change that,regardless!.Www@Enter-QA@Com

1stly!. is she leaving!? that possiblity is very unlikely!. yes that was a grave mistake that raised many questions!. but still, there always being rumours about idols' credibility!. u know like if the producers are manupulating the show etc!.!. so ppl are soon gonna forget this !. her mistake doesnt means ppl will shut their tv every week, i wont!. so are millions of people out there so it really doesnt affects much i think!. and with ryan's vague explanation on result show, it may not help much but i think he's answer is enough to calm some of audiance down !.

even if yes she is leaving!. they probably find someone her age, thats blabbers everyweek!. its nice of her to be a little encouraging to the contestants by looking positively at their performances even though there are flaws!. but most of the time she's covering too much of the truth in her comments which is not the best way to help them coz they need to know how well they truely did!. then again, why would they sack her!. simon and ryan is the base of this show!. the other base will be simon and paula!. plenty like to see how they bicker!. haha! especially when someone raise awkward questions during the call in!. so its has effects to the public, they wont sack her!.Www@Enter-QA@Com

She's not leaving!.!.!.and about Idol losing it's credibility!.!.!.it hasn't had any of that for several seasons now!.


And also, how is it that their critiques are scripted based on dress rehearsals, but Paula still can't come up with any original thoughts/words!. Geeezz!.!.just imagine how she would blabber on if it WAS done on the spot!.Www@Enter-QA@Com

Naomi Judd is well respected, has been a judge on other shows and would really add some class that is lacking in IDOL right now!. I'm thinking Paula is having health problems again and is back on her pain killers, In April 2005, she revealed that she suffers from a rare neurological disorder called complex regional pain syndrome (CRPS) that causes chronic pain, people always blame it on booze with her & I don't know perhaps it is!. However from personal experience I know how Rx drugs that are required daily can affect a person & I know she was or is on some extremely heavy duty narcotics heavier then what I take!.!.!. personally I won't take such strong drugs but hey that's me!.Www@Enter-QA@Com

She's not going to be fired!.

If anyone leaves that show that show will fail and it'll be the end of it!. If they are going to replace people they'll have to replace everyone and change everything!.!.!.!.!.

The chemistry would be all screwy!. It wouldn't work!.

Plus Paula takes medication for her hurting back!. It seems to have affects on her state of mind and makes her lose track of time and what words to use!.!.!.that's why Simon, the mean one, tends to try and guide her to an end!. he's actually looking out for her more than making fun of her!.

The way she is doesn't bother me!.Www@Enter-QA@Com

Paula isn't going anywhere she's part of the show!. Judd!?!? all she is a Paula wanna be like Hasslehoff is a Simon wanna be!.I won't watch any show they judge!. Simon, Paula, and Randy are the best where Idol are concerned!. Jessica Simpson!?!?!? omg you've got to be kidding!.!!! Anyone other than Paula would only try to copy her antics and would suck at it Ellen is great comedy but it's not but it's not American Comedy Idol right!? Although the auditions can be comedicWww@Enter-QA@Com

Yea I agree, she has been saying to loopy things lately, I agree I think the Janet Jackson should take her place, Janet has been around for a while and she knows her stuff, and I doubt she will have run in's like Paula did!. Remember that guy she tried to hook up with, one of the contestants!.Www@Enter-QA@Com

And what makes you such an authority!? It WAS just a small mistake that people blew out of proportion!. Ryan set the record straight!. People make mistakes!. Period!. She won't be fired!.Www@Enter-QA@Com

Is that show still on!? That is so 2006!.Www@Enter-QA@Com



The answer content post by the user, if contains the copyright content please contact us, we will immediately remove it.
Copyright © 2007 enter-qa.com -   Contact us

Entertainment Categories