What's the deal with Brooke White on American Idol?!
Question: What's the deal with Brooke White on American Idol!?
I was almost 100% positive that she was going to go home this week, but instead it was one of my top 3 pick Carly Smithson!. Carly was clearly one of the best singers this season!. I think Brooke is probaly the worst singer out of the entire top 12 because she is very limited and will not make it in the music business with that plain, mediocre
voice!. If she gets a record deal, they will drop her the same way they dropped Taylor hicks because no one will buy it (who wants to buy an album with all the songs sounding exactly the same!?)!. I am so bumbed that she outlasted Carly of all persons!. Why do people keep voting for her!? Is it because she can play the guitar and piano!? It sure isn't because she has a good voice (beacuse she doesn't)Www@Enter-QA@Com
voice!. If she gets a record deal, they will drop her the same way they dropped Taylor hicks because no one will buy it (who wants to buy an album with all the songs sounding exactly the same!?)!. I am so bumbed that she outlasted Carly of all persons!. Why do people keep voting for her!? Is it because she can play the guitar and piano!? It sure isn't because she has a good voice (beacuse she doesn't)Www@Enter-QA@Com
Answers:
finally!!! someone with a brain!!!
i agree with you 100 percent!. well make it 99 percent!.
why is because i dislike jason a heck of a lot more than brooke and id rather listen to her butcher another song than have to hear or see jason!.
carly was one of my favorite contestants on the show (besides david cook) and i was soooo upset to see her go!. i mean i know she wasnt going to win but i think she deserved the publicity more than brooke or jason!.
but dont sweat it, theres no way that either of them will win considering the davids are on the same season!. they've pretty much got final two in the bag!.
and im thinking that a big reason as to why brooke wasnt in the bottom was because of votefortheworst!.com!. shes their new victim and vote for her every week now that kristy lee cook is gone!.Www@Enter-QA@Com
i agree with you 100 percent!. well make it 99 percent!.
why is because i dislike jason a heck of a lot more than brooke and id rather listen to her butcher another song than have to hear or see jason!.
carly was one of my favorite contestants on the show (besides david cook) and i was soooo upset to see her go!. i mean i know she wasnt going to win but i think she deserved the publicity more than brooke or jason!.
but dont sweat it, theres no way that either of them will win considering the davids are on the same season!. they've pretty much got final two in the bag!.
and im thinking that a big reason as to why brooke wasnt in the bottom was because of votefortheworst!.com!. shes their new victim and vote for her every week now that kristy lee cook is gone!.Www@Enter-QA@Com
Agree 100%Www@Enter-QA@Com
I know, I was shocked too!. I thought for sure she would have been booted this week!.Www@Enter-QA@Com
i know i think that Brooke should of gone home!. Carly was one of the better ones!. I think even Brooke thought she was going home!.Www@Enter-QA@Com
She does have a good voice but i was sad cuz i liked carly too!.david a!. or jason need to go!.Www@Enter-QA@Com
Apparently, according to Paula she has a large fan base!. This show has become a popularity contest not a singing contest so that means Archuleta will win!. He can sing but I'm not that crazy about him!.Www@Enter-QA@Com
Carly just didn't have a solid fan-base, I think!.
Everyone else had obvious people that would vote for them, but Carly had random people of all ages and cultures!.!.!. That's not enough in American Idol!. You need to appeal to a specific group!.
I really liked her, though!. I really thought she was going to make it to the top 3 based on her performances!. I never quite figured out why people were giving her such a hard time!.
Brooke was really lucky this week!. I would be majorly surprised if she made it past next week!.Www@Enter-QA@Com
Everyone else had obvious people that would vote for them, but Carly had random people of all ages and cultures!.!.!. That's not enough in American Idol!. You need to appeal to a specific group!.
I really liked her, though!. I really thought she was going to make it to the top 3 based on her performances!. I never quite figured out why people were giving her such a hard time!.
Brooke was really lucky this week!. I would be majorly surprised if she made it past next week!.Www@Enter-QA@Com
I like Brooke, I think she has a good voice, but she isn't my favorite!. I thought for SURE she would go home last night!. I thought her and Jason would be in the bottom two!. I don't like Jason AT ALL but I know he has a bigger fan base than Brooke!. So, when they weren't in the bottom two and CARLY went home I was shocked! I don't think Brooke will be the next American Idol though!. I think it will come down to the two Davids!.!.!.!.!.!.!.!.Www@Enter-QA@Com
me too!. I was pissed when they kicked off Micheal also!.
I sorta think Syesha will pull it out from behind and win!. She is in the bottom a lot but, She still hangs on!.Www@Enter-QA@Com
I sorta think Syesha will pull it out from behind and win!. She is in the bottom a lot but, She still hangs on!.Www@Enter-QA@Com
she would be gone by now if it wasnt for her looks!.!.!.Www@Enter-QA@Com
Everything got messed up since Sanjya ( or however u spell his name)Www@Enter-QA@Com
Votefortheworst!.com is claiming Brooke's failure to be booted last night as a win for their mission of!.!.!. well, voting for the worst!. Whether that's true or not, she somehow managed to get enough votes!. Additionally, limited doesn't always mean bad!. Look at Norah Jones!. One could argue that she's very limited and who would want one of her cds!?
She definitely is on borrowed time, because she just isn't that good and other contestants seem to have much larger fan bases!. Me, I'm wondering why people keep voting for Jason Castro! I think he's awful!.Www@Enter-QA@Com
She definitely is on borrowed time, because she just isn't that good and other contestants seem to have much larger fan bases!. Me, I'm wondering why people keep voting for Jason Castro! I think he's awful!.Www@Enter-QA@Com
brooke does have a nice voice!.!. but i was shocked that Carly left over her!.!. carly is not the best singer this season there is others that are alot better!.!.!. IMO atleast!.!.!. she is good and i like her, but i believe that the guys have it won this season!.!.!. David A and David C are clearly the best of the season!.!.!.!.Www@Enter-QA@Com
I don't get it either!. I liked Michael Johns!. and I'm very concerned that the little weeny David Archuleta is going to win!. He reminds me a dark haired Clay Akins!. Creepy!.Www@Enter-QA@Com
She looks a little psycho crazy to me!. They may be afraid that if they cut her she will poison everyone!.Www@Enter-QA@Com
Brooke's very cute and definitely more marketable than a Taylor Hicks or Ruben Studdard!. She's a singer-songwriter, which adds a different dimension!.
Carly, as I wrote in another thread, has a bunch of issues that did her in!. Primarily, many viewed her as a "ringer" because she already had a major record deal!. Plus her song choice was very dated!.Www@Enter-QA@Com
Carly, as I wrote in another thread, has a bunch of issues that did her in!. Primarily, many viewed her as a "ringer" because she already had a major record deal!. Plus her song choice was very dated!.Www@Enter-QA@Com
honestly like Brooke is not that good of a singer n Jason n her should go home!. because if it comes down to them 2 in the finals they will never sell albums like anybody else can!. because brooke genre isn't really popular shes a folk person!. n u cant really put a white dude wit dreadlocks n nice blue eyes n a category!. Now can u!? this competition has nothing 2 do with singing but more with how much America loves wut ur wearing n wut u look likeWww@Enter-QA@Com
One can't help but wonder if the fact both Brooke and David A are Mormon plays a part!. Voting is based on much more than talent, unfortunately!. There is a huge backing in America for this non-Christian faith!.Www@Enter-QA@Com
it is because she was chosen for votefortheworst!.com so she is getting extra votes!.
i hope that david archuleta wins!.
:DWww@Enter-QA@Com
i hope that david archuleta wins!.
:DWww@Enter-QA@Com
i like brooke, but i also liked carley!.
i think one of the guys have 2 go!.
also brooke is hott!.Www@Enter-QA@Com
i think one of the guys have 2 go!.
also brooke is hott!.Www@Enter-QA@Com
All of the remaining contestants are pretty whack!. I'm almost positive that this years winner is going to spark the lowest cd sales in Idol history!.!.!.Www@Enter-QA@Com
i agree!. I think it is a popularity contest!.Www@Enter-QA@Com
i know! that is exactly what said! Brooke White(or brooke wine as i call her) is this year's Sanjaya!. aka ai is rigged!Www@Enter-QA@Com
I thought that Brooke was going home also, but I disagree with you!. Brooke is my favorite and I love her!. She's a great singer that just made a mistake!.Www@Enter-QA@Com
I disagree!. Carly has a strained voice and Brook's voice is not strained when she sings!. Her type of music will probably get her in the end because she has more of a Carly Simon or Carol King style!. I think this style is too old fashioned for most of the American Idol fans!. But her personality is so adorable!. That is probably what saved her this week!. Carly on the other hand I didn't care for and I wouldn't buy any of her albums!. And there are many people out there that feel the same since they never bought her last album!. But I would buy Brook's album!. But bottom line is music preference is a choice!. What one person likes doesn't mean everyone else will!. And Carly does not have the most talent of all the performers left!. So technically she would have to go eventually!.Www@Enter-QA@Com
its because she has this HUGE hard core Christian fan base that is hoping she will like be their representative or something, I mean, I am Christian but I am not going to vote for someone who sucks just because they are oneWww@Enter-QA@Com
I agree with you 100%!. I was so sure that either Brooke White or Jason Castro wouldve got voted off the show last night!. I was royally pissed and shocked when Carly got voted off the show last night and even more shocked when her and Syesha ended up in the bottom 2!. WTF!. Carly and Syesha out-performed Jason Castro and Brooke White Tuesday night and both are way better singers than Brooke and Jason!. Carly was easily to best singer on the show!. America votes the wrong people off American Idol every year!. American Idol has become all about POPULARITY!. The show has become a POPULARITY CONTEST!. The show has become a BIG FAT @ss JOKE!. American Idol is a singing contest!. Its supposed to be about finding the best possible singing talent not whos the most popular!. WHAT A DAMN JOKE this show has become!. Brooke White and Jason Castro better singers than Carly and Syesha is laughable!. Brooke White and Jason Castro has a bigger fanbase than i thought!. Thats how theyve made it this far!. Their fanbases have voted them through!. Carly got voted off cause of her lack of popularity!. If she had been real popular with the big audiences that watch the show every week she wouldnt have been in the bottom 3 let alone getting voted!. This POPULARITY Crap sucks @ss!. What a JOKE!. Hopefully some record label saw Carly on American Idol and will give her a record deal!.Www@Enter-QA@Com
dude!! i was 100% sure she was going!! i though her and Jason (even though i like him) were going to be in the bottom 2!. but Syesha and Carly were!! they were the best of the night!! Brooke doesn't do anything exciting with her voice!. i mean shes a good-ish singer!. but not for this competition!. plus it was too far into the competition for her to stop and start over like that!.!.!.again!.!.Www@Enter-QA@Com
and when the hell is that syesha going home!?!?!? soooo annoyingWww@Enter-QA@Com