American Idol Fans..... (SPOILER)?!


Question: American Idol Fans!.!.!.!.!. (SPOILER)!?
Did Carly Smithson deserve to be cut last night!?

I'm not a huge Carly Smithson fan (I'm a David Cook fan), but you have to admit she is -- was -- the strongest girl in the competition!. And Jason Castro yawned his way through another performance, while Brooke blundered again! What's the deal!?Www@Enter-QA@Com


Answers:
!.!.!.it's simple, this isn't a "talent" contest; it's a "popularity" contest! And Jason Castro stays in because of the gaggle of teeny-poppers voting for him! He is the worst singer (and I use the word 'singer' loosely) up there and I thought (and hoped) for sure he'd be gone!Www@Enter-QA@Com

I agree!. Carly should not have left!. I thought for sure it was either going to be Brooke or Jason!.

Been a fan of Carly and David Cook since day 1!. =)Www@Enter-QA@Com

Well, apparently Brooke has a huge fan base according to Paula and that is why she wasn't voted off!. I really thought it was going to be her last night!.Www@Enter-QA@Com

Jason Castro should have left a long time ago!. Syesha did well last night but I think she should've left before Micheal Johns did!. Carly Smithson should not have been cut!.Www@Enter-QA@Com

i totally agree with you!.she should be top three as Simon said!.Www@Enter-QA@Com

I think she should of stayed!.I want David Cook to win thoughWww@Enter-QA@Com

I agree!

I think Carly Smithson is the best female singer left, Syesha is 2nd and Brooke is 3rd!.

Among males, I'm surprised Jason Castro is still running!. He should have gone early in the top-12!. Maybe he's colleagues are voting for him!.Www@Enter-QA@Com

idk i am thinging the same as youWww@Enter-QA@Com

Jason going to win because of his Grandpa!.!.!.!. Fidel!. He has ordered his nation to vote for JasonWww@Enter-QA@Com

She didn't deserve to be cut last night and i agree with you 1OO% [: ;; Carly was the strongest girl and her performance was awsome - from her vocals to the way she organized ittt !. I think Jason or Brooke should have been eliminated buht since the competion turned into a popularity competion ; that's what happened ! ; Buht even with the popularity competion ; i thought Carly has a large fan base ! =O !.Www@Enter-QA@Com

It's a popularity contest, carly is not as appealing as some of the others even though she has a way stronger voice!. at times the way she dresses is very almost trashy, while brooke is very wholesome, and jason has the girlies vote!. to me carlie wouldn't be very marketable aside from her voice!.Www@Enter-QA@Com

okay agree on the david cook part ;) disagree with the carly thing nobody liked her from the beggining and since american idol is a more of a popularity contest then a talent competition she left personnaly for me she wasnt that great like she screamed everything in that pitch that made the back of my hair stand up so i wasnt shocked to see her go!.!.!.!.GO COOKWww@Enter-QA@Com

Unfortunately, American Idol has turned into a popularity contest rather then what it is, a singing competition!. There is no way Carly would have been kicked off last night if people voted for talent and not the person!. I don't personally like David Cooke as I feel he is too high on himself!. However, I voted for him multiple times this week because in my eyes, he was the best one!.Www@Enter-QA@Com

No, she did not deserve it @ all and Syeisha should have not been in the bottom 2 either cause both of them were awesome last night!. I was never so shocked in my life, she was one of the strongest women in the competition!. I thought Brooke and Jason would of been in bottom 2 and i figured Jason would of went home!. Him and Brooke are both talented but neither of them are an American Idol!.Www@Enter-QA@Com

1st off Jason didn't yawn his way through the performance!. He yawned backstage last night more than likeley because he was simply tired!. Isn't yawning an involuntary reflex!? If David A!. did it and they showed it on screen the little teentards would be fainting all over the place because they would think it's adorable!. When contestants start getting criticized for yawning then that tells me a whole lot about the voting public!.
2nd, I thought the point of this show was to vote for your favorite each week!? So, if Jason is someone's favorite why should they not for him because he had an off night!? They all have those now and then!. During season 4 my favorite was Bo Bice from the beginning but even if he had an off night I still voted because he was my favorite!. I cannot stand people who only are fans when their team is winning!.Www@Enter-QA@Com

Hazy Daisy too the words right out of my mouth!.!.!.!.!.!.

Carly should not have left!.!.!.!.!.!.!. it should have been either Brooke or Jason!.

Though I do like Brooke, she's a cutie =)Www@Enter-QA@Com

Carly was the best vocalist on the show hands downWww@Enter-QA@Com

The US voters went crazy!.!.that's whyWww@Enter-QA@Com

carly didnt deserve the boot-off!.!.!.she is by far the strongest girl in the competition!.!.been a fan since day 1!.!.!.brooke shouldve left!.!.!.!.jason!.!.!.untouchable because of the fans!.!.!. :(Www@Enter-QA@Com

broke got her base vote, then the pity vote when she fell apart, and she got the votefortheworst!.com vote

i just couldnt stand looking at carly, and it is not the tattoos, she looked like a demon with that hook nose, and she dressed like she was a size 3 teenager, she isnt fat but she looked horrible in the clothes she picked week after week

just like johns, she was a plant brought in to avoid the 'sanjaya effect', so like johns, she will make some off hand remark about sanjaya in the exit interviews, oh and the ratings are down since sanjaya left!.

if snajaya wasnt the best thing to hapen to that show, why was a 7th place finisher given a solo performance in the finale!?Www@Enter-QA@Com



The answer content post by the user, if contains the copyright content please contact us, we will immediately remove it.
Copyright © 2007 enter-qa.com -   Contact us

Entertainment Categories