American Idol- What The Heck???!

THANK YOU!

My jaw dropped when I heard Brooke was safe & Syesha was in the bottom two!. My jaw completely dislocated when I heard Jason was safe & Carly was in the bottom, joining Syesha!. I've got to give kudos to the deaf Americans who made today's terrible & amateurish decision possible! We just lost the best female vocalist & one of the best performers in the competition!. She is much more vocally strong than Brooke or Jason, & definitely more entertaining & versatile than David Archuleta!. How she left before any of them, I'll never know!.

My favorites were Carly & David Cook!. Now that Carly is gone, there is only one hope that the winner of this season will be one who deserves it, considering factors such as talent, consistency, charisma, personality, & everything else!. I didn't expect Carly to win, but after a TERRIBLE performance like that from Brooke, there is no way Brooke should've stayed longer!. All hope lies in the Cook!Www@Enter-QA@Com

---

---

I'm stunned and P!.O'd!. Wasn't everyone sure that Brooke and Jason would be in the bottom two!? And Jason would probably go home!?!? Every year there are these shockers that we just can't understand!. I thought Carly was the best singer!. America really effed up this time! :(Www@Enter-QA@Com

---

---

CARLY IS SO AMAZING AND SUCH A GOOD SINGER!!
WTF AMERICA!? YOU TOTALLY GOT IT WRONG!!

I VOTED FOR 2 HOURS STRAIGHT FOR HER LAST NIGHT AND EVERY OTHER NIGHT!

this is soooo gay, it should be brooke or jason that left! i like david cook, but its not gonna be the same without carly there! she brought alot of life to the show, and i loved her personality! idk, but at least she went out on a rocking song! and i know she is gonna be insanley successful and have tons of albums, i cant wait! im gonna be the first to buy it!

i was seriously bawling my eyes out! but seeing carly smiling and not crying made me love her even more!! shes soo strong and beautiful!! most people are like crying hysterically when they leave!. she was just thankful for everything and happy! but she so should not have left! ughh, and her little journey video thing made me cry more, its soo sad!!!


GO CARLY, ROCK ON FOREVER BABYDOLL :]
cant wait for the album!!Www@Enter-QA@Com

---

---

I sooo agree with you on this one!!! Before the show started, i thought that brooke or jason was leaving!. then i saw carly and syesha in the bottom two (which was shocking because i thought they were better than brooke and jason), and i knew it had to be syesha who was leaving!.
but when ryan said "carly your leaving" my jaw litterally dropped!.!.

woahhh wrong decison!!! i'm gonna miss carlyWww@Enter-QA@Com

---

---

I called it last night!. Carly was going this week!. Her style is fake and people saw that!.
She's not a glamour star and pretends to be!. She's NOT humble but pretends to be!.
She was the last of the fakers!.
The top three should be Brooke, and the two davids!.
I do think Syeshia is good but she also lacks that genuine quality, even though I feel she is genuine!.

IMHO, I think David Cook is the best!.Www@Enter-QA@Com

---

---

Simply pathetic! It's okay that you stop & restart again, but come on, this is the 2nd time Brooke does this! It really shows that AI is about popularity & not about talent! The best of them all is David Cook hands down!!!!Www@Enter-QA@Com

---

---

i never liked her!. her accent was annoying!. plus she has had a record contract before!. SHE NEEDS TO GIVE OTHER PPL A CHANCE!!!!Www@Enter-QA@Com

---

---

I totally agree!. Carly and Syesha were the bottom two, when they had two of the best performances the night before!. Jason and Brooke, who completely tanked, were safe!. Those two should have been the bottom two, and Jason should have gone home!.

I'm just glad that David Cook is still here!. I was worried that he might suffer because he sang his Andrew Lloyd Webber song straight instead of trying to infuse it with a rock edge!. I think he is wonderful and should win the competition, hands down!Www@Enter-QA@Com

---

---

People with no lives must really want to sway the vote! I think people voted many, many times for last nights worst, i!.e!. Brooke! Because of that stupid website, votefortheworst!.com! *Sigh*Www@Enter-QA@Com

---

---

I'm so sad for her I want her to be in the top 2 or 3 but badly carly has to go home
i want brooke to go home
but all i want to win is David C
here's the top 3 in the compitition
top 5:
going home syesha or brooke or jason

syesha is safe
jason is safe

going home : brooke

top 4:
bottom 2:
syesha
jason

syesha safe

jason home

top 3
David C
David A
Syesha Mercado

bottom 2

syesha and david A

going home syesha

top 2
David A and C

Winner: David Cook

the 2008 winner is David CookWww@Enter-QA@Com

---

---

i was stunned!.
i was certain brooke was going ( i love brooke, btw) but come on this is a talent show!Www@Enter-QA@Com

---

---

wHAT A BUNCH OF craaaaaaaap!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!Www@Enter-QA@Com

---

---

A lot of people had it out for her since the beginning because she had a record deal before so they thought it wasn't fair for her to compete on a show with amateurs or they hated her tattoo or thought her husband's a freak, or had some other reason they didn't like her!. I love Carly,though,and think she has an amazing voice so I'm sad to see her go!. But I know this isn't the last we'll see of her, she'll have a very successful career!. Plus, she finally impressed Simon, which seemed to be her personal goal all along, so at least she went out on a good note!.Www@Enter-QA@Com

---

---

well obviously not alot of people thought thatWww@Enter-QA@Com

---

---

I thought that she should have at least made it to the top 4!. But I'm actually not surprised that she got voted off because every year, one of the best singers never makes it as far as they should have (ex: Melinda last year should have won)!.Www@Enter-QA@Com

---

---

I cant believe carley was voted off, she was amazing last night!i have been with carly from the start! the results of the show were horrible!. when syeshia was standing there with brooke, i thought brooke was going because syeshia was amazing the other night and then the same thing happened when jason castro was up there with carley!. Jason castro should have gone, he was horribe, he couldnt sing memory with his little wimpy voice!

Oh well, david cook is still in the competition which makes me happy!. didnt you love when he sang the music of the night!? thats one of my favorite songs from the phantom of the opera!. Go David Cook!Www@Enter-QA@Com

---

---