Why did they eliminate Michael Johns last night from American Idol on the Idol G!


Question: they gave all the contestants a free get out of jail card pass for the week and then the following week they eliminated 2 people. It just seemed to be in poor taste to eliminate Johns last night. This was supposed to be a week of Idol Gives Back, about giving and donating money. The producers really messed up big time on this, and also Ryan Seacrest made himself look like an A S S, you agree? He made it sound like the entire bottom 3 would be safe until next week, but then he told Johns that his road ends here. It's too bad for the Aussie, I liked Johns. He picked the wrong song though, Aerosmith's Dream On. He tried to hit those high notes at the end and really tanked on them, but he should've been given a pass until next week. Big thumbs down to American Idol for that, you agree?


Answers: they gave all the contestants a free get out of jail card pass for the week and then the following week they eliminated 2 people. It just seemed to be in poor taste to eliminate Johns last night. This was supposed to be a week of Idol Gives Back, about giving and donating money. The producers really messed up big time on this, and also Ryan Seacrest made himself look like an A S S, you agree? He made it sound like the entire bottom 3 would be safe until next week, but then he told Johns that his road ends here. It's too bad for the Aussie, I liked Johns. He picked the wrong song though, Aerosmith's Dream On. He tried to hit those high notes at the end and really tanked on them, but he should've been given a pass until next week. Big thumbs down to American Idol for that, you agree?

I agree 100%. Ryan Seacrest goes a little too far sometimes when he's trying to surprise America. The producers are messing up everywhere this year. I think American Idol is coming to end. I don't think this will be the last season, but it's well on it's way to failure.

Well I too was shocked but I still like American Idol

That was so poorly done. I really like michael johns and expected him to be in the top 3. It is so unfair that 'singers' like kristy lee and syesha are still in while he is out. I really liked his version of dream on.

I sill like the show but that was so disrespectful of Ryan. Mike thoght he was gonna stay. He was one of the best vocalists there! At least he gets to be on the tour. :) He has a GREAT future ahead of him! Looks like Ryan is gonna be on The Soup tonite, hehe. <3

Well, you know it had to be one "shocker" this week. And I'm just as confused as you, cause I could have swore Syesha was going home! I mean, only Fantasia can sing "I believe" period, she blew it outta the box! Syesha sounded like a wannabe Tuesday night, and I thought Michael Johns did the best.

Now if only Kristy would stop being endorsed by votefortheworstdotcom, then we could celebrate!

Oh yeah, and Ryan was a major douchebag last night -I mean, more than usual.

they should have waited yes, and that song was a little big. that song is to big for anyone, except Aerosmith.

yeah that's so true
I can't believe Ryan would put up someone's hope that high
then bam!
it's back down it's soo sad

you know, i've read so many questions today about michael johns. i don't understand the outrage of him leaving. even if they were not going to eliminate anyone this week, he would of left next week. he has been below average at best and when he sang dream on, it was horrible!!
i do agree what ryan seacrest said was terribly mean. adding salt to the wound. why would he agree to say that?
i read on here that people think it a money ploy. he will come back next week due to the outrage of idol fans and the fans will look to fox as they love and respect their viewers...i don't know if that true but it does make me think...

american idol is really getting too gimmicky. remember how they surprise us last season that they didn't eliminate anyone on idol gives back week but they first announced that it's gonna be the most shocking elimination night... and now this season, they flippin sent the wrong guy home. ughhh im so mad right now about it. and what the hell is that Kristy Lee still doing there?!?!?

Is there a place to file a "formal" complaint with American Idol?? Regardless of who was eliminated, Ryan went over the top with this one and I think that there should be an apology made!! No good this week for American Idol!

I Think Last Year They wanted Jordin Sparks to succeed, and she is, But I think If they did Same this Year Micheal Johns win the whole Thing, They want to do It again so they send Packing, Big Thumbs what a Cheap *** Display that was.

USA got ir SOOOOOO wrong
I'm so shocked right now.
How could theu eliminate him at this stage?!?!
Come on!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

I am in shock over Michael Johns leaving last night, I just can't believe it. I seen the shock of the audience, the judges, the people all over the internet, everyone is in shock. I don't know if he would have won, but I think he should have been in the top 3. It also blows me away that Kristy Lee Cook is still there, she is this years Sanjaya. I don't even think she did her song justice this week, it sucked if you compare it to Martina Mcbride, but it was okay for her, I mean she doesn't have the best vocals and it was one of her better performances, but it was no where near good next to Martina, and how can you not compare it to Martina, when Martina was on that stage last year and sang that very song.



The answer content post by the user, if contains the copyright content please contact us, we will immediately remove it.
Copyright © 2007 enter-qa.com -   Contact us

Entertainment Categories