Spoiler: American Idol 4-10-08: Who SHOULD have gone home?!
Question: If not Michael Johns, who do you think SHOULD have gone home tonight?
Answers: If not Michael Johns, who do you think SHOULD have gone home tonight?
Syesha.
KRISTY LEE COOK... she should have left WEEKS ago!!!
Kristy Cook!!!!!! ahhh shes soo boring and plain. grrrrrr
Kristy.
syesha
she may sing well "technically"
but she doesn't EVER connect like the others
at least kristy connects on SOME
level
even though i still hate her!
SYESHA!! SHE'S BEEN IN THE BOTTOM THREE FOREVER!!! YES SHE HAS A BEAUTIFUL VOICE BUT PPL MUST OBVIOUSLY NOT LIKE HER IF SHE'S STUCK THERE!
jason, kristy. syehsha, brook, david a
JASON JASON JASON
HE SUCKS
Y DIDNT THEY THINK THAT IN DA FIRST PLACE
THE OTHER ONES ARE GREAT
JASON ISNT EVEN STAR MATERIAL
syeisha...should've never even made the top 24! so i'm anxiously awaiting her departure from the show...
Kristy Lee Cook. She sucks and has the stage presence of a slice of bread. How she slipped under the radar again and beat out someone with the talent of Michael Johns is beyond me. I think alot of people are voting with their penis's out there and should spend more time listening to how she sings rather than how she looks. It's a singing competition people!
Kristy Lee Cook! She should have been the first person to go home!
KRISTY.......you know, the one who can't sing. But she fits the profile, so I guess she gets to stay.
SYESHA. Or KLC, although somehow everyone thought she was amazing this week. So Syesha and Kristy will be the next two to go. THEY BETTER!
i totally agree with Kimberly. kristy cook. she shouldn't have even been in top 12.
i hate it that michael johns had to go. he's my favorite of all.
Kristy Lee Cook or David Cook.
Either Kristy Lee Cook or Jason Castro. Kristy stays because of votefortheworst.com but I can't figure out why Jason stays! It's not that he doesn't have talent, but he is the most predictable person up there. Every performance of his is the same. It sounds the same, he goes through the same motions, he just changes the song! Could you imagine what one of his concerts would be like? Snore fest!
BROOKE WHITE!! Why does everyone like her so much? Her kindness is fake, she has a range of about six notes and she can't hit ANY high notes (which EVERYONE can hit better than her,) she plays the piano during every flippin' song, she was PRETENDING to be upset when Michael (who should have STAYED!!) left, and most importantly, SHE HAS NEVER DONE AN UPBEAT OR LOUD SONG IN THE HISTORY OF THE SHOW!! Plus, when she was in the bottom last week, she wasn't CRYING because of DOLLY PARTON. Why couldn't she just have SAID, "I don't want to go home?" Seriously! Why does everyone like her?!
America really IS a bunch of crap. Which explains why Bush is our current president.
Carly, because you can see it in her eyes.
kristy lee cook by a long shot..she has sucked it up since the beginning..i mean she was in the bottom three AND the bottom two how many weeks in a row?
i totaly think that chrisy should have gone and even though the irish chic can sing i think she should go cause she already had a record deal and it was a bust.
Michael Johns I stick with.
He ruined all in the name of Aerosmith with that shitty version.
JASON CASTRO---he is a total dweeb who doesn't know know to comb his hair and cannot even speak intelligently--HOW could he possibly be an American Idol??? He doesn't sing that great either. He is just weird looking.
The bore with 3 names.
Kristy. But, if I had to choose from someone in the bottom 3, Carly. I hate her. For some reason. She seems like a stuck up ***** and her favorite AI moment was when Sanjaya was eliminated. That's very rude! Syesha is hanging on by a thread. I see her going next week unless hse REALLY outdoes herself. In which case, I would LOVE to see a Carly or Kristy elimination. Or a David Archuleta elimination in the top 4 or so. I don't like him as much as other people like him. Sorry.
Kristy.
Syesha is second to go home but she is GREAT compared to Kristy. Kristy has what? 2 octaves? Plus she has the worst vibrato I have ever heard in my life. She is a kiss-up to the red states. She cannot choose songs to save her life. She has a terrible personality. She dresses with cleavage showing. She is stiff on stage. SHE IS ONLY HERE BECAUSE SHE IS PRETTY, & SHE NEEDS TO GET OFF THIS SHOW.
KRISTY LEE COOK!! to bad its just a popularity contest,she is just the Sanjaya of season 7.personally i think she is horrible id rather listen to people die then her.i change the channel when shes signing no lie.Poor Mike Johns =[
among the 3, should have been syesha. but in general, should be kristy lee cook
it's sad to see michael johns go. on a positive note, there could be some recording company waiting to get him.
Syesha why is she still here,she has a one tone voice,and she is fake.Diva!!!!!
Now on a nice note she has a good voice,but not an Idol voice.
Kristy Lee Cook!
Either Syesha or Brooke White.
Syesha because, though she has a beautiful voice, her stage presence is somewhat lacking.
Brooke White because she is bland. She has no diversity in her style.
Ideally, in a perfect world it would be David Archuleta because I am so irritated by his little boy mannerisms.