Who do u think would win if all previous american idol winners competed against !
Question: For those who do not know: the previous winners are Kelly Clarkson, Rubin Studdard, Fantasia, Carrie Underwood, Taylor Hicks, and Jordin Sparks.
Answers: For those who do not know: the previous winners are Kelly Clarkson, Rubin Studdard, Fantasia, Carrie Underwood, Taylor Hicks, and Jordin Sparks.
For sheer talent, it will always be Kelly for me. Carrie might win a popularity contest, but let's see her write, produce AND perform her own material. Kelly's already done that three times over.
Carrie Underwood.
hmm thats kinda hard..
i think it would be either Kelly, Fantasia or Carrie
Carrie Underwood
I seriously dont know ! Carrie Underwood is like my IDOL ! but kelly clarkson has a amazing voice ! but i would have to say carrie underwood ! She can sing acapella and low notes awesomley ! xoxo
Kelly Clarkson
Kelly Clarkson, hands down.
She's the only TRUE american idol.
she's amazingg<3
I Would think Carrie Underwood would appeal to the masses... however Kelly will always be number one.
It would either be Kelly, Carrie, or Jordin based on their fame now. Carrie has sold more records or topped the charts more than the others according to the American Idol show so possibly her.
the best previous american idol winners are
best first
Carrie Underwood
Kelly Clarkson
Jordin Sparks
Fantasia
Rubin Studdard
Taylor Hicks (we all know duaghtry is the real winner)
Im gonna have to say Kelly Clarkson. I like Carrie and Fantasia too but i seriously think that Kelly would win if all the former American Idol winners would compete against each other.
I think Kelly, 'cos she can sing a lot of different types of songs. Carrie is great, but mostly only country.
Good question! It would be between Carrie Underwood and Kelly Clarkson.
Ooooh good question! I think it'd be either Carrie or Kelly. Probably Carrie!
carrie underwood
or kelly clarkson
Carrie Underwood. Her following and success has eclipsed everyone else.