Who's your favorite judge on American Idol? Do you agree with him/her?!
Question: Randy! Love him. Paula is sweet and nice, which can be good to hear when your up there in front of thousands of people, Simon tells it how it is and he's dreadfully honest which is great, but Randy is my favorite. He's down to earth, he tells the truth but in a nicer sort of way, more creative critisism than anything else. He'll tell you if he loved it or if he hated it, but not in a way that will totally break your heart. He's awesome!
Answers: Randy! Love him. Paula is sweet and nice, which can be good to hear when your up there in front of thousands of people, Simon tells it how it is and he's dreadfully honest which is great, but Randy is my favorite. He's down to earth, he tells the truth but in a nicer sort of way, more creative critisism than anything else. He'll tell you if he loved it or if he hated it, but not in a way that will totally break your heart. He's awesome!
simon, cause they all do really suck...
all of them
SIMON!!! most of the time i agree with what he says. sometimes i think he's a complete and utter jerk who should just shut his trap.
i don't really watch american idol cause it's not really my kinda music, but when i have watched it Simon told them exactly what he thought and i liked that
I like all of them...
Paula is really funny
Simon may be a bit cruel but hes so bloody right most of the time!
Simon bec ause he makes great tv with his caustic comments.
I agree with him most of the time although he has been known to show unfair bias. Give him his due he admitted he was wrong at a later date.
SIMON...MOST TIMES I AGREE WITH HIM BECAUSE HE'S DIRECT WITH HIS REMARKS & THAT HELPS THE CONTESTANTS TO DO A BETTER HOMEWORK...
Honestly none of them. They are hardly ever on the same page with me. I agree with them differing each time. One time I'll agree with Paula, the next Simon, then Randy. Though tonight Simon I think was having a bad day or something because usually he's not that far off and today I thought most all the performances were great. The Exceptions:(Syesha, Carly, and Ramiele) The rest were really good.
Simon
Simon Cowell-----He tells it like it is. No holds bar with him and instead of people disliking him, they should take his advice and grow with it because he is in the music business and knows what's hot and what's not.
Simon, he is right sometimes.,
I like all of them, but Simon is my favorite. He's honest and isn't afraid to say what he thinks.
I agree with him 99 percent of the time.
Simon because he is brutally honest.
I like them all, Simon is bluntly honest and what he says is usually true.
Definitely Simon, he is usually the most accurate. Randy is unfortunately very predictable "Dawg, let me tell you that was hot!" or "a little pitchy, not your best", "Oh, dude, I don't know.." those are usually the kind of comments he makes. Classic Paula was the one a few weeks back when someone had a lot of "colors" going on, does anyone remember that bit of nonsense? She's gotten a little better criticizing the contestants but overall she's too wishy-washy.
Simon, he always tells the truth.
ummm my favorite is simon. hes the most entertaining..however sometimes i dont agree with waht he says. he has this wonderful ability to judge people based on their personality instead of whats important-their signing. but he is hilarious. paula is really twisted and cant say anything for herself and randy is cool but hes becoming a lot like simon. hes alright though. simon is just a character. oh and soemone please tell me if simon and paula are into eachother because im pretty sure simon is all over that. am i wrong?
Generally Simon, but he is always a b*tch when it comes to country music. He seems to be overly critical of Jason( my favorite) of late and that is pi ssing me off.
I guess I'd have to say Randy. I used to like Paula but this year her comments just get on my nerves SO bad. She babbles on and on about nonsense like "your aura is wonderful" blah blah blah...talk about how they sang the song! I do like Simon (in a way) because of his honesty but I think you can be honest without being cruel and brutal.
Simon, because he just puts it out there. He has no tact, but he knows what he's talking about..
Randy...I think hes fair...hes not rude like Simon is paid to be, but hes still honest about his opinion! And Paula...half the time I just tune her out...she repeats herself every week!