Is it just me, or is simon from american idol really mean to some contestants?!


Question: yeah he is pretty mean at times but hes simply giving his opinion and sometimes its just not pleasant.
you have to think of it this way: would u rather have a judge who is honest and mean or someone who tries to be nice to everyone and lies to make sure nobody gets mad at them or cries?
id take simon.
but yeah he is a lil mean but its probably just his honestly sprinkled with some tv drama is all


Answers: yeah he is pretty mean at times but hes simply giving his opinion and sometimes its just not pleasant.
you have to think of it this way: would u rather have a judge who is honest and mean or someone who tries to be nice to everyone and lies to make sure nobody gets mad at them or cries?
id take simon.
but yeah he is a lil mean but its probably just his honestly sprinkled with some tv drama is all

No, he really is mean to some people. But I honestly love it. He's so brutally honest. It's quite entertaining, especially at the auditions.

to me, i find it hilarious to see people's faces when he does.
Simon is just saying what he thinks
and i honor that.
but sometimes it is a little too much.
soo, i'm kinda like half half here.
:]]

He's not mean......... he's honest........remember the truth hurts.

I think he is just being totally honest, really, some of those people don't stand a chance. I am sick of Ryan and his little barbs to Simon all the time.

i don't think that he is "mean".. i guess he could be a little nicer to the people who suck, but he just tells them like it is.. i would rather someone tell me the truth, than someone butter me up and act like i can actually sing.. and if the people ever made it to the industry, they probably would be treated the same way..

and i mean he can do whatever he wants.. he's signing the record deal..

hes not mean just honest and why shouldn't he be isn't it his record company they will be signing with so if they suck he loses money

no he justs says what some people should really hear to get their own life and use their brains a little more

You're right, he can be really mean.

i agress he can be an *** sometimes

He is not mean,he's truthful.

yeah, but i appreciate that he tells the truth. i saw an interview of him on americanidol.com and he said why he does that- check it out if ya want but i do agree, he could be a little nicer.

I agree with you but he is the only one that is really honest with them.Paula loves everyone and they may sound terrible,and no comment on Randy.

I think sometimes it unnessecary but most of the time he being honest. I mean, when you have Randy sugar-coating it, and Paula being like "You look great" (which has nothing to do with the ability of the contestants singing voice) Simon has to be the one who tells them the truth.



The answer content post by the user, if contains the copyright content please contact us, we will immediately remove it.
Copyright © 2007 enter-qa.com -   Contact us

Entertainment Categories