Are you happy with American Idol's Top 12?!
Question: if not, who do you think should or shouldn't be there?
Personally, I would trade David H and Kristy Lee (especially after their disasters this week) to have Danny and Asia'h back.
I think Josiah should be there too, but he's probably better without Idol.
Answers: if not, who do you think should or shouldn't be there?
Personally, I would trade David H and Kristy Lee (especially after their disasters this week) to have Danny and Asia'h back.
I think Josiah should be there too, but he's probably better without Idol.
I don't know who I'd trade out, but I would definitely bring Danny & Asia'h back - more Danny though. I cried when he got voted off :( but hopefully it won't be the last we see of him.
i like david archuleta
yes, josiah, was a Huge let down, but the Australian is good, and JakeezyEzyy is good too. :D
That show is still going on? What is this, American Idol 32?
I agree with you. Although David Archuleta is my absolute favortie of all time, Danny and Asia'h were really good. I like Amanda Overmyer, but I think that sometimes she yells so much its hard to understand her. I think this year the idol is going to be one of the boys. (cough, David Archuleta) I totally agree with you about trading.
well, last week when it came down to asia'h and kristy for the girls, i think asia'h should have stayed...and based on the performance tonight, i think asia'h could have done a lot better on a song than what kristy did...plus, i think danny should have stayed, though i truly don't know who he would be traded with...i would have chosen him over chikezie[or however you spell it], but if i could personally pick someone out to place danny in, it would have to be david h. i think the top 12 is just ok, but i think the "rockers" in the competition get praised too often, but when someone comes out and sings a ballad, the judges are never satisfied...
:]
that's just my opinion...
josiah was alrightt.. but i dont think i would have him in the top 12..i would want joey catalano in the top 12 (the one who couldnt sing in round 2 b/c of the flu and strep throat)and i would want asia'h back... but besides that....
DAVID ARCHULETA IS GOING TO WINNN <3 =] !!!!
Hmmm, I think Kristy Lee Cook is going home tomorrow. She did awful tonight and the judges hated her performance.
I liked Asia'h...I wish she wouldn't have left :(
yea i guess, the only one i like is Ramiele Malubay and David Archuleta is ok
i wish alaina whitaker would come back i liked her she was sweet and good too. her first performance was amazing!!!
Yep for the most part. I think asia'h should be in the top 12 instead of Carly. And otherwise I think we have a pretty good top 12. Better than last year for sure. I do agree that David H. was a disaster tonight, I'm thinking he will probably leave this week. I also think Archuleta was a Disaster but he has done really well in the past so he will make it through no problem.
My favorite is Brooke White. Her performance earlier tonight was I think the best this season. I just helped create a new Brooke fansite and you are welcome to come and look around and join if you want.
http://brookewhitefans.net/index.htm