I'm not sure I understand...American Idol?!
Question: Why everybody thinks Brooke is so good... she just never seems very special to me...
Answers: Why everybody thinks Brooke is so good... she just never seems very special to me...
I don't know. I wonder that too. I come across Brooke as annoying and just plain weird. I really don't like any of the girls this year except Ramiele who needs to step her game up. And amanda also bothers me and scares me rather. I think this season's winner will be a boy
I'm with you. I have not been at all impressed with her. I think the only girl I like that is left now is Amanda Overmeyer.
they are in a contest to sing the best and jujes like when you add things to songs
brooke is not that special I like carly smithson
is that the blonde, carly simon/carol king-esque who plays piano? i think she's pretty good. perhaps unique is more the right word.
ME EITHER
*barf barf*
she sucks
She reminds me of Carly Simon. She is awesome. And very REAL. And Pretty too.
Brooke White, she may not have changed the song arrangement like a couple of other contestants did tonight but boy was she good! (and last week and the week before, etc...) I think this was her best performence so far and the best performence of the night! Her vocals were amazing and she showed emotion unlike many other contestants. And as the judges say, It's a singing competition, and she was great and i think she will win this season.
By the way, I was right last season
She is very good. She is like a natural. She is also very sweet and likable...she has a very sweet nature. She also comes off as being very real, and not stuck on herself...I just wish she would go to a buffet a few nights a week.
I don't understand why Amanda Overmyer even made it past Hollywood round. I would listen to Brooke over Amanda any day. Blechhhh.
I agree . pretty girl, nice teeth but a really boring singer and to make matters worse she picks one of the lamest Beatle songs ever written to sing
I think Brooke is one of the top 2 females on the show. She is very talented.
I find it interesting that the ones of us that are fans of Brooke are not fans of Amanda.
:)