Of the past American Idol winners, who is your favorite?!
Question: Who do you feel really deserves to be the American Idol and who do you think should never have won?
Answers: Who do you feel really deserves to be the American Idol and who do you think should never have won?
the person that should have won is melinda doolittle, my favorite is lakisha, ( I don't remember her last name). the b bop guy should not have come in second over melinda or lakisha.
Kelly Was good she deserved to win... and the others... no comment
i like carrie underwood.
Kelly Clarkson b'coz she rocks!!
i love KELLY!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Carrie Underwood is my favorite by far.
Carrie and Kelly
Fantasia Barrino, Love her voice and her Story of her Come up
kelly was the best! carrie is really good if you like country.
hands down.....taylor hicks, reuben and fantasia should have never won! jordin sparks is okay.....but she will never be a powerhouse like kelly and carrie.
carrie underwood
Carrie Underwood is my favorite. I think she, Kelly Clarkson, and Fantasia have done great jobs. I think Reuben Studdard sings well but that Clay Aiken should have won. I thought last year was pretty boring. Jordin Sparks is good but not an "Idol" type. And my least favorite and the only one I really, truly think has failed the whole concept of the show is Taylor Hicks. Daughtry or even Elliott Yamin should have won. Taylor Hicks is only marginally talented and while Katherine McPhee has a nice voice she lacks in the personality department.
kelly i think deserves the prize .
My favorite has to be Taylor Hicks. He's my first choice
My secong would be Carrie Underwood
Third, Clay Aikman
I think Fantasia should not have won.
def jordin sparks and carrie underwood.
i love tattoo
Carrie is my favorite. I don't know that Taylor Hicks should have won.
Kelly Clarkson, The Best, La Mejor
Carrie Underwood tied with Taylor Hicks, although... I really think Chris Daughtry should have won.
Hands down, do doubt about it Kelly Clarkson! The one the only ORINGINAL American Idol!! As for who didn't deserve to win...Taylor Hicks! Horrible!
Carrie Underwood (and Chris Daughtry but he didn't win)
Fantasia
In my opinion Carrie Underwood is the best and Rueben shouldn't have won because he's nowhere, we don't hear from him like we do with other winners.