Is Dannii right?!
Question: She said Phoebe is carrying the rest of Hope. I think so, and also has Simon done an almighty ****-up with the song choice? I thought so, Hurt is one of my favourite songs and it was badly done. It's Si fault really, Phoebes voice ain't strong enough to carry a song of that magnitude- Not many singers can tho.
Answers: She said Phoebe is carrying the rest of Hope. I think so, and also has Simon done an almighty ****-up with the song choice? I thought so, Hurt is one of my favourite songs and it was badly done. It's Si fault really, Phoebes voice ain't strong enough to carry a song of that magnitude- Not many singers can tho.
Yes she is the best singer - the rest of the group are her backing singers (The Woo-woo girls), and boy, they DO NOT like it!!!!!
i agree with you. any money hope are in the bottom two tonight
SEE WHAT DID I TELL YOU
She does carry the rest of them, they hardly sing, just hum and hee in the background!
As for the song, I read that Simon wanted them to sing a Supreme's song, but they wanted to sing that one so he backed down and allowed them to have their own way.......wonder why that was?
Yes! Dannii was COMPLETELY right! If it weren't for Phoebe, Hope would have been out weeks ago! She is the only thing holding them up! Simon did a cr** job of choosing their song, they are a band not PHOEBE! You can't say Hope sang that song, Phoebe did! So I hope they are out tonight, even though Phoebe doesn't deserve to be off! But what can we do?
Simon wanted them to sing a supremes song , they had a strop and they persuaded Simon to change the song , yes Danni is right Phoebe's better than the others and they should have put her through in the female category , another thing they've messed up on this years x factor lol
i agree with danni about Phoebe i thought she has a good voice but hope are not my favourites
think your maybe right.
yes and i think they have had a lot of fighting like Mrs said they wanted to do own song so Simon has had enough and thought go on push off hang yourself.
yes your right and thats why i believe that hope will be out tonight.
yes she carrys the group but only cause they dont sing as much. they can all sing as they have all had a go, but tonight was a bad song choice and i think simon knows that as you could see it in his face as they performed. i think hope will be bottom 2 along with nicky.
If Phoebe is the best singer in the group I don't hold much HOPE (sorry about the pun) for them. They are all hopeless.
simon didnt choose the song they did, hope are crap, pheobe cant sing and neither can the others they should just go back to their day jobs!
yes
i think that she was right that phoebe had carried them, but i think that phoebe has carried them since the beginning. But then again they did pick bad bunch of girls in the first place.
They have to go tonight!!!
I was thinking that last week as well - Phoebe does all the singing and the others are her backup.
I haven't liked Hope from the start though - I hope they are out tonight.
the whole show is fixed anyway
I think Pheopbe should have been put through on her own, saying that even if she had she would have been gone by now!
For once -Dannii was right
Right on all accounts Sweet as Phoebe is the only one in that group who can sing and I think she will have a solo career ahead of her. Simon should have remained strong and made them do his choice. Hurt is for a solo singer not a group.