Which movie or televsion version of "A Christmas Carol" is your all-ti!


Question: I think I still favor the ever conservative Alex P. Keaton as Scrooge in "Family Ties."

Answers: I think I still favor the ever conservative Alex P. Keaton as Scrooge in "Family Ties."
The 1951 B&W version staring Alistair Sim as Scrooge.

I'm a Christamas Carol junkie and I'll watch a TV show I've never watched before if I find they're doing a version. I've got 6 copies of the story and pick up every version I find on DVD (or VHS). I had 2 VHS tapes full of different TV versions (lost them, long story) I even found the old Mr. Magoo version ;) Oh, I've also seen it done live once and hope to again!
I meant "A Christmas Carol" although I am addicted to "A Christmas Story." Some of it was filmed in my neighborhood--the mall part where the children slide down the pretend snow. Report It

Other Answers (4)

="shown">
  • Downriver Dave's Avatar by Downriver Dave
    Member since:
    September 12, 2007
    Total points:
    3997 (Level 4)
    ="network">
  • Add to My Contacts
  • Block User
    • Easily the best is Scrooged with Bill Murray.
    My favorite version of "A Christmas Carol" was a one-man stage performance which I saw Patrick Stewart perform at my college. Got to sit down and talk to him for a few minutes at the foot of the stage after the show -- this was at the apex of my Star Trek: The Next Generation -geekdom, so it was a REAL thrill.

    Of the television and/or film versions... Hmmmm - I think the Muppet's version with Michael Caine was pretty darn good!
    My all time favorite is the original in black and white.
    The 1938 version.

    The answer content post by the user, if contains the copyright content please contact us, we will immediately remove it.
    Copyright © 2007 enter-qa.com -   Contact us