Best Reasoning -10 points?!


Question: Ok, you are the judge. There are 2 groups of men. The first group contains 1 innocent man and 9 guilty men. The second contains 9 innocent and 1 guilty man. The 1 guilty man in the second group killed someone very near and dear to you. Which group do you choose to die and why?


Answers: Ok, you are the judge. There are 2 groups of men. The first group contains 1 innocent man and 9 guilty men. The second contains 9 innocent and 1 guilty man. The 1 guilty man in the second group killed someone very near and dear to you. Which group do you choose to die and why?

I would choose the 2nd. Because I can first rule out the single suspect in the 2nd group and it would be less time consuming and more effective. (If I am to support my near & dear one,which I would do in any case) Am I wrong? lol

Oh you mean the court orders whole group to die? *scratching my head*

I didn't get your Q exactly!!!

P.S. I wish to know the best reasoning from you soon.

The first group, I knwo that my loved one that passed would not find justice in killing 9 innocent people.

The 9 guilty men because they'd deserve it. To honor the person near and dear to me I'm sure they'd want me to do choose the one in which the whole world benefited instead of revenge of one person.

the first group

i choose the first because 9 are guilty andu only lose 1 innocent live and save many many many more
while the other man who killed your person stayes alive and cant hurt as many people as 9 others would together

I CHOOSE THE GROUP WITH PIE.

Neither. I would let GOD and the DEVIL Deal with them.



The answer content post by the user, if contains the copyright content please contact us, we will immediately remove it.
Copyright © 2007 enter-qa.com -   Contact us

Entertainment Categories