Who's more talented.. James Hetfield or Dave Mustaine?!


Question: mustaine BY FAR. hetfield is just a rythm player and all he really plays are chords mostly. dave on the other hand plays rythm and leads and writes most of megadeths music himself. lead and rythm. hetfield is ok at what he does but mustaine is the better PLAYER. just cause hetfield is in the "more popular" band doesnt make him a better guitar player. remember, mustaine was in metallica too. my vote goes to mega dave on this one.


Answers: mustaine BY FAR. hetfield is just a rythm player and all he really plays are chords mostly. dave on the other hand plays rythm and leads and writes most of megadeths music himself. lead and rythm. hetfield is ok at what he does but mustaine is the better PLAYER. just cause hetfield is in the "more popular" band doesnt make him a better guitar player. remember, mustaine was in metallica too. my vote goes to mega dave on this one.

Definitely James Hetfield. Dave Mustaine never really had any talent to begin with. It's no question... well, in my obviously no-so-humble opinion. LOL!

for metallica-hetfield
for megadeth-mustaine

didn't care for mustaine being in metallica..

Mustaine, that's why he started his own band. Because they're better then Metallica.. ^(^-^)^

Dave Mustaine is more talented with the guitar and James Hetfield has a better voice so based on their album sales I'd say James is more talented.

hands down i think dave mustaine is a better guitarist..but james just knows how to work the crowd..and he can write some pretty awesome stuff which dave mustaine only writes a killer song every once in awhile..so i think they kinda even out..if your looking for some killer riffs you go for dave but just an overall good song james..(you prolly should have compared with kirt hammet instead of james hetfield)

idk... i cant decide

on guitar, I have to give it to Mustaine, he can shred that axe.
but
for Vocals: Hetfield can deliver much better than Dave.

Thus.... It's a tie in my mind.

are you kidding me??? listen to their music, its not hard to figure out....... hetfield has no talent, none

Are you talking about vocals or guitar playing? As for playing, I'd say Mustaine. As for vocals, Hetfield hands-down.

Definitely Mustaine. Hetfield could never play Holy Wars or anything like it. Any yokle can play St Anger.

Dave is a way better guitarist. He can shred with the best of them. His signature snarling vocals have grown on me but they still can't match James' gruff voice. James really dominates Dave in vocals.

i say mustaine...he wrote alot of riffs that metallica use...such as the master of puppets and the four horsemen...before metallica were sell outs with all their new **** basically from the black album-up mustaine was there....and i seen mustaine live in concert and he like use his thumb as a capo on the 12th fret and was shreddin on like 16-24 fret...so i'm going with mustaine..u can also hear some of those riffs he wrote in some megadeth songs....sorry for the long answer

Dave is a better guitar player for sure!

they are both angry. lyrics and music i would have to go with megadeth. nobody in megadeth has left the band or been kicked out. ha ha

Its just personal opinion. Theyre both way better than me.



The answer content post by the user, if contains the copyright content please contact us, we will immediately remove it.
Copyright © 2007 enter-qa.com -   Contact us

Entertainment Categories