MCR fans: What makes MCR "Metal"? A lot of MCR fans I've known cla!


Question: I've spent a couple years listening to many Underground Metal bands but I still don't see why many of their fans assume they are Metal. Even on their myspace page they claim to be Metal. To me it seems they are the farthest away comparing to the bands I listen to.

Inform me. I'm wondering. No I'm not a fan as you can see. Lol.


Answers: I've spent a couple years listening to many Underground Metal bands but I still don't see why many of their fans assume they are Metal. Even on their myspace page they claim to be Metal. To me it seems they are the farthest away comparing to the bands I listen to.

Inform me. I'm wondering. No I'm not a fan as you can see. Lol.

MCR is about as metal as Yellowcard and FOB! HAH! Even the thought of MCR being metal makes me giggle like a school girl! TeeHee!

LOL MCR can never ever be metal..
Maybe they just dont know what metal is.. hahaha.

Yes, MCR is way too hardcore for me. (Sarcasm)

If they were ever considered Metal, then they would be placed under the genre of metalcrap, also known as metalcore.

I thought they were influenced by the Smashing Pumpkins

they are no where near metal

Ew they claim to be metal on Myspace? Don't they have people to check those kinds of things?

I have no idea, but this question ranks right up there with the likes of the location of the holy grail and the JFK assassination conspiracy, one of the greatest mysteries ever.

One of their guitarists liked metal.

But that doesn't make them metal.

MCR is the Milli Vanilli of Metal lol. Heck I don't even consider them rock at all, they're more like poser pop!

They wear black and play harder music than the Jonas Brothers. To people who only listen to teeny boppy music, it is the hardest thing out (aside from Nickelback, which is also metal to them)

And it just sounds so hardcore to say "I'm a metalhead"

So that's why some of their fans consider them metal.

The rest of the logic is lost on me.

HAHAHAHAHAHA!!!!!! MCR is metal! And so's my grandpa's polka band! HAHAHAHAHAHA!!!

MCR Metal? WTF!!!!!!!!!

They just think we're stupid, nothing in their music is a characteristic of being metal. They are emo, but like everybody bash emo, they want to defend themselves and therefore claims they're metal, which is not true. If they dont want to call themselves emo, then they should fall in crappy music, maybe in new school punk, post-hardcore, or whatever. These sub-genres fall in the punk umbrella, that doesn't mean punk is alive, which died a long time ago and now is referred as old school punk.

Well, I asked a question a while back for the Fans to turn me on to their favorite songs. I was surprised to hear a punk influence, nothing remotely , even in my wildest dreams metal though. I don't even think it was good punk though.


That is as polite as I can put it.

bullshit! They never were and never will be metal.

You've confronted them. You know that the Emo doesn't like to be confronted when they are caught posing.
Most people that answered your question aren't actually MCR fans...

"OmG liEK MCR is TeH neW Mayhem!!!1!1"

Hey! MCR r not Metal.... If its true I say "Oh MotherF*cker"... Hahaha....

Because their fans have never actually listened to metal, only pop rock.

Dream on MCR and MCR fans, you'll never be metalheads

Oh my god. Dear sweet baby jesus.
I have never heard a MCR fan refer to them as metal, but if I ever do I will punch them in the head.
I didn't believe you, so I just checked their myspace page. That is really sad that they actually think they're metal. If they ever actually meet a metal band in real life, I'm sure they'd get their asses kicked.
*cringe*

WTF hahahahahaha MCR metal ewww only in those sad wemo kids dreams
"OmG oMg Im LyK sOoO GaWwThIc iM gOiNg To LiStEn To tHe BlK PaRaDe IM SoOoOOoO MeTAL"
just let the freaky try MCR kids think what the listen to is metal

bah. metal?
i knew most of the little emos/scenies say they are metal, but the band themselves?!?! this is news to me.
not only is it news t me, it is also extremely insulting to me. I apologise for not being able to answer your question, but this is... well, its confuzzling, bewildering, flabbergasting and gobsmacking. now theres four words i dont use often. if anyone can really answer this question, then either they're lying,or they're Jesus. or both.

MCR "Metal"? NO WAY!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

I love MCR...they play with their lyrics well and aren't afraid to be a little different..but there is no way they are metal..they may give a pueny scream here and there..maybe a few heavy riffs..but that doesn't mean they are metal..bands like Trivium and KE are metal...i don't think they could pull metal off anyways..



The answer content post by the user, if contains the copyright content please contact us, we will immediately remove it.
Copyright © 2007 enter-qa.com -   Contact us

Entertainment Categories