If you are a music/song writer, what do you think of American Idol?!


Question: They dont write their music or lyrics. There are a bunch of fake wannabe rockers that put on the "bad boy" image. lol


Answers: They dont write their music or lyrics. There are a bunch of fake wannabe rockers that put on the "bad boy" image. lol

im not sure how everybody else feels but in my opinion its a bunch of people trying to get famous without having to work for it like a real musician.

Very few of them have any talent; There are 'pop' stars and then there are real musicians.

Well not everyone was blessed with the talent to write. Just like the people who are writing and not singing. They weren't given the talent to sing. Everyone should just use the talent that they have and quit judging others for the ones they lack.

Well we've only just got American Idol put on our tvs in Australia I love it so far it's so entertaining people can't sing they literally go through thousands of train wrecks until they find the most popular next big recording artist. Not all of them are rock wannabes most embrace singing melodies in hudge and that I admit can be boring to watch all these ballads. But this year is been the toughest competition yet according to the promos. Your either gonna love it or hate it but they truley have the number one highest rating show on television.

I can understand why some people go on about 'how these shows are ruining the music industry'. That's rubbish. Shows such as American Idol and the X Factor are trashy and fun for some people to watch. We do sometimes get introduced to talented singers but they are NOT musicians. Case closed, look at Kylie Minogue - very successful but she doesn't write her or material or play an instrument. There is enough room for all of them I say.

They are TRYING HARD to make NAMES in the MUSIC INDUSTRY.



The answer content post by the user, if contains the copyright content please contact us, we will immediately remove it.
Copyright © 2007 enter-qa.com -   Contact us

Entertainment Categories