I need some honest criticism?!
Question: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=U30jrOz30...
It is me singing and playing the piano...dont be cruel please...
Answers: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=U30jrOz30...
It is me singing and playing the piano...dont be cruel please...
I didn't think the piano was out of tune, but I might listen again and hear one or two notes but I usually pick up on that.
Voice is possibly a diamond in the rough. On the whole, not bad. Don't hang on to your "R"s as in waterrrrrrr. Soften the "R"s. High notes are within your range but you haven't found your voice for that yet.
Usually, when someone is starting out they play the piano loud or hang on th sustaining pedal. If you hold the pedal down too much, it muddies the song, but you didn't do that.
High notes appear to be in your range but control will come with practice. The key may also have something to do with it. I doubt that you're at the point where you can transpose piano music on the spot to a higher or lower key. I hated that.
Oh, very pretty too.
not bad.......american idol is coming to city near you!!!
I think you're wonderful. I really enjoyed watching you play, and your voice is sweet. Keep at it!
You're probably not the next American Idol, but you aren't horrible...maybe make piano your thing.
aww you're really talented! HONEST! I think you have some real potiental! Keep with it and you never know what might happen!
It's very nice! I really enjoyed the video!
i think its good
I have always been a sucker for a chic that can play the piano..., If I were wanting to be an American Idol judge on teh singing I think I would go with a Randy Johnson type let down....
your "PRETTY" good at playin da piano
I think you are BRAVE and wonderful to put yourself out there, like you did! I think you have some basic talent, maybe work with a vocal coach to speed you along! Good luck to you!
Ps> I can only play the easy part of Heart & Soul!
I think you did very well, playing the piano and singing at the same time can't be easy. I mean, you're not the BEST singer I've ever heard, but you've definitely got potential. Maybe some singing lessons to learn some tricks of the trade and you'll be off to a great start.
you said honest criticism so ppl may be mean...
anway thats not the point..
umm yea paino was good...
=/
you have a real good voice and I think with lots of practice and a bit more effort you could be famous!!!
I wouldn't pursue either as a means of making money, but I think if you enjoy either you should continue, because you could become good, but probably not great.
practice more.
well, in all honesty, the piano is really good... keep up the practice... the singing, you need to be LOUDER.. open those pipes up girl. pitch is okay, it wouldn't hurt to kick it up a notch.
good luck!!
WOW I love your smile...!
You are very good at piano, but I think maybe if you sit up more you can hit the high notes a little better. But you are very good! =]
What song is that by the way??? You can IM me to let me know.
you are really
good
it was rough around the edges but it was ok just pick a song that is less high pitched like i said before.
Lovely girl, lovely song, decent piano playing, singing is a little flat. You just need more practice. Don't give up.
I like it. It's not bad, not amazing. Pretty talented. You definitely could go somewhere with a few singing lessons. Good luck! You got my vote!
the piano sounds pretty good, but your voice isn't that great. you're kind of pitchy -- you especially seem to go flat at the end of lines. work on building breath support so you can keep the pitch up where it needs to be.
I'm a musician too - I know what nasty criticism is like, so I'll be nice :).
You've got a nice tone of voice and the piano is good. You look very nervous, though. You're not letting go, losing yourself in the music...that's what it's all about! Let yourself go. Find a song you absolutely LOVE and play it like the world's going to end. Passion. There's a quote about music that I love: "Music is what feelings sound like."
Good luck :). Keep going!!! Add me if you fancy a girlie/music chat.
The piano playing is very good but the voice sounds like you may need work. Or it sounds like you're speaking the words. Im not trying to be cruel. Just giving honest feedback. Its always important to any musician to get honest feedback.
Pretty good!!! Fantabulous!! Audition for American Idol. I'll vote for you!!! And buy your album when you win!!
I thought you were going to be something more like this.......
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EwTZ2xpQw...
a lady was in the hospital lobby playing a harp on saturday,you remind me of her.
piano was good voice not bad at all but getting a vocal coach can help. But overall good job
You are really really good, but remember to stay on key when you hit high notes. Your piano also needs a little bit of tuning. But other than that, I'd give you an 8.5. Well done!
I almost shut it off at 27 seconds, but decided to keep on listening. I lasted for another 20 seconds or so.
Your tone is flat and off key. It was rather boring. As was the piano. There was no feeling involved, just ho hum.
But, I have to give you major kudos for putting yourself out there.
I really think that you sounded good. The piano was wonderful. Keep up with the singing. You are young and you definitely have potential.
Sorry, you voice is as bad as mine and should never be used in public.
Stick to singing in the shower.
PS you asked for honesty.