Classic or new??!


Question: charlie and the choclate factory do you like the classic or the one with johnny deep?


Answers: charlie and the choclate factory do you like the classic or the one with johnny deep?

i like the johhny depp one better.
the other one is just plain creepy

I like both! but the newer one i find so wonderfully psychedelic! and i like any music by danny elfman.

classic

the new one was creepy, I like tim burton's work but not this one

the new one's okay, but nothing beats the original. it's wayyy better.

the classic....johnny is actually kind of creepy and not so inviting as Wonka. I prefer the old one.

you can't remake a classic. thats like trying to remake the wizard of oz

I love the classic though the new one stays closer to the book and was pretty good.

I like the johnny depp one better, cause the old one is more creepy sounding, and looking....but that's just me

What a tough question.

Sure the Tim Burton one is great. But I was really disappointed that it wasn't more like the book, because the whole squirrel thing was in the promos. And they completely annihilated a chance for a "Glass Elevator" sequel. And while it's great that they used the book's lyrics in the songs, I really missed "Pure Imagination".

And Johnny Depp is really creepy in this, too; he emulates Micheal Jackson, which probably seemed like a good idea at the time.

Gene Wilder lights up the screen with his performance, and while the songs are cheesy (except for "Pure Imagination",of course) and the special effects are questionable, kids still are glued to the original even to this day.

I'd have to go with classic.

Classic...............but I still love Johnny Depp



The answer content post by the user, if contains the copyright content please contact us, we will immediately remove it.
Copyright © 2007 enter-qa.com -   Contact us

Entertainment Categories