Book fans concerning HP5?!


Question:

Book fans concerning HP5?

Ok, guys. I have read the book, and love the series. There were definitley things cut from the movie that were in the book, but really this movie is the most faithful adaptation of HP yet (excluding the first two, because they are so cheesy, LOL). What, really, is so offensive about the cuts in this one? The cuts made in PoA and GoF were abominable but this one wasn't bad. So what's got your wand in a knot?

Additional Details

2 weeks ago
Yeah, they cut out some really great stuff from the book, but they will never make a 3 or 4 hour movie, unfortunatley. So, what I'm trying to say is, with all the restrictions they have to contend with, the movie is really good. :)

2 weeks ago
Yes, you are right, the one thing that bothered me was how Sirius died. But they can easily explain that away should they need to (if it turns out he's not dead). Really, the movies already depend on the viewer to have a knowledge of what happened in the books. I've already dismissed the idea that people who haven't read the book will understand, so I just suplement what happens in the movie with what I know from the book. :)


Answers:

well ive been reading a lot of complaints about the movie saying that they took off a lot of things from the book. But they do that everytime they cant be word for word or the movie would be days long. anyway ive also been reading that the storyline is good and the stuff they take out doesnt affect the movie. WHATEVER im gonna have my opinion on friday when i see it!! haha yeah!!


The answer content post by the user, if contains the copyright content please contact us, we will immediately remove it.
Copyright © 2007 enter-qa.com -   Contact us

Entertainment Categories