Is Harry Potter and the Order of the Phoenix good?!


Question:

Is Harry Potter and the Order of the Phoenix good?

Well the title says it all.


Answers:

I just got home from seeing Harry 5 and I have to say that I am quite disappointed. 5 was my favorite book and I know it really well. They cut so much and changed so much the the movie hardly works. It was fragmented and disjointed and lacked the luster of previous movies.

They cut out almost everything at Grimauld place, they quickly glossed over the romance between Harry and Cho, they quickly glossed over Mr. Weasly being attacked by the snake and cut entirely the hospital and etc. They cut out Ron and Hermione being prefects, they cut entirely Ron joining the quidditch team, Harry, Fred and George being banned from ever playing, they cut quidditch out of the movie entirely... They cut entirely everything about Rita Skeeter and Harry's tell-all interview, they cut out most of what happened in the department of mysteries...

The 5th book was filled with so much emotion, the movie lacked all of it. I walked away at the end of the film feeling really let down, which saddens me because I love the books, especially 5, and I loved the movies, especially 3 and 4.... but movie 5 just wasn't what it could have been.


The answer content post by the user, if contains the copyright content please contact us, we will immediately remove it.
Copyright © 2007 enter-qa.com -   Contact us

Entertainment Categories