If the New X-Men had a fight who would win?!
Question: I think maybe X-23 or Hellion. Or Dust. Then again Elixir could kill everyone...
Answers: I think maybe X-23 or Hellion. Or Dust. Then again Elixir could kill everyone...
Elixir has been stated as being Omega Class but he is not yet skilled enough to use his powers to that degree. X-23 is heads and tails above anyone else. She has the training, the skill, and the ruthlessness to take out any of the others.
Wallflower and Icarus are dead so they are non-factors. However, Icarus' regen powers were dependent on his wings so X-23 could easily rid him of those and with her training and healing factor we don't know that Wallflowers' powers would work on her.
With the exception of Wither and Dust none of the other students really have any powers to do sufficient damage to X-23. As far as Wither's powers go we don't know how much of an effect they would have on X-23.
In Ultimate X-Men #41 there is a kid who had similar powers to Wither's. He radiated toxins and acid like poisons around him that vaporized organic tissue. When his powers manifested he killed at least 265 people. Nick Fury sent Wolverine to kill him so they could cover up the incident as a chemical accident.
The kids powers didn't have any effect on Wolverine so there is a chance that Wither's powers would have no effect on X-23. If they did have an effect we don't know that he would be able to kill her. Finally, He has to touch X-23 and if he is that close he is already dead.
Dust would be her biggest threat. She has been shown to strip flesh off bone in her dust form. Depending on the writer X-23/Wolverine might be able to regenerate from that. So it really becomes a toss up between the two.
Come on!!! The new X-Men would never fight with each other!! They are way to busy fighting evil mutants. I dont really know the answer. It would be a toss up. :)