Who came first, mandy or rihanna?!

Question: who came out with the song umbrella first mandy moore
or rihanna??

---

---

Answers: who came out with the song umbrella first mandy moore
or rihanna??

---

---

rihanna
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BMB6YOWzQ...
^^ PROOF! Mandy Moore even SAID that it was originally sung by RIHANNA

---

---

Rihanna came out with it first, but Mandy Moore decided to make a slower version of it.

---

---

Rihanna i thought

---

---

moore has an umbrella song?

---

---

As far as I know, Rihanna did, but it was supposed to be for Mary J. Blige.

---

---

mand came first
rember on the princess diaries she ame first

---

---

RIHANNA... DUH.

---

---

Rihanna came out first.............hit me up sometime on messenger if you want

---

---

mandy duh

---

---

Mandy Moore came out with the first Umbrella song, Rihanna has been around for like what 2 months for that song, Mandy has been around for YEARS!

---

---

RIHANNA DUH! but mandy moore is sweet

---

---

mandy moore!!!

---

---

i think it was rihanna i don't really care though!~

---

---

i think rihanna =]
i did not even know that mandy moore had an umbrella song?

---

---

Rihanna, of course, came first with the Umbrella song. However, Mnady Moore started her singing career in 1999 with her hit song "Candy:. And she starred in a few roles like " A Walk To Remember" in 2000. *sob* beautiful movie...Mandy ends up with cancer a the end..= [

---

---

Rhianna
She made that before mandy.
Mandy wanted to make a slower tribute to umbrella.

---

---

---